The study of Aristotle in the Aristotelian Society in the 1970s as an indicator of the special historico-philosophical style of British Philosophy

The article aims to present the study of Aristotle’s teaching on consciousness and soul conducted by the well-known contemporary scholar of ancient philosophy, Jonathan Barnes, as an example of a certain historical-philosophical style that emerged within British analytic philosophy as a whole and within the Aristotelian Society in particular during 1970-1980s. It is shown that the development of the historical-philosophical style within the Aristotelian Society at this time continues the tradition of slow reception of ideas from continental philosophy, which was noted already in the early period of Society emergence and development. This is explained by certain theoretical isolation that had developed by this time in British philosophy, which had its imprint on historical-philosophical studies and is expressed in the application of conceptual analysis and the inclusion of its results into the modern philosophical context. Although Barnes considers Aristotle’s teaching on consciousness and soul through the prism of contemporary versions of physicalism and dualism, the question of what role the Aristotelian teaching plays for them remains unanswered. The author puts forward the thesis that in this case, J. Barnes’s analysis of the Aristotelian problem of consciousness and soul appears less productive than the previously developed approaches in scholasticism and phenomenology in the continental history of philosophy.

1. Aristotle. On the Generation of Animals. M.: USSR Ac. of Sci. 1940. (In Russian)

2. Aristotle. On the Soul // Works: In 4 vol. Vol. 1 / Ed. by V.F. Asmus. Moscow: Mysl’, 1976. (In Russian)

3. Aristotle. On the Soul. M.: Gos. sots.-ekon. izd-vo, 1937. (In Russian)

4. Baldwin T. Th e Original Choice in Sartre and Kant // Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 1979. vol. 80. p. 31–44.

5. Barnes J. Aristotle’s Concept of Mind // Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 1971. vol. 72. p. 101–114.

6. Brentano F. The Psychology of Aristotle νους ποιητικός // History of Philosophy Yearbook. M.: Nauka, 2003. P. 308–340. (In Russian)

7. Didikin A. B., Belyaev M. A., Nexaev A. V. et al. Aristotelian Society: 140 years of philosophical dialogues. M.: Prospekt, 2021. (In Russian)

8. Husserl E. Works: In 3 vol. M.: Gnozis, 2001. Vol. 3. Logical research. (In Russian)

9. MacKinnon D. The Presidential Address: Idealism and Realism: An Old Controversy Renewed // Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 1977. vol. 77. P. 1–14.

10. Orlov E.V. Aristotle on experience and the mind in the Second Analytics II, 19 // History of Philosophy Yearbook. M.: Nauka, 2003. P. 34–68. (In Russian)

11. Rorti R. Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. M.: Russ. Fenomenol. ob-vo, 1996. (In Russian)

12. Vdovina G. V. Intentionality in medieval and baroque scholasticism // Filosofskii zhurnal. 2020. Vol. 13. No. 3. P. 23‒37. (In Russian)