J. Ladyman, D. Dennett and E.J. Lowe: How the electron exists

The paper aims to answer the question: «How does an electron exist at the beginning of the 21st century?» from the point of view of the general logic of the philosophy of science discourse, taking into account con­temporary philosophical concepts that explain what an «electron» is, and in what sense we could talk about the «existence» of such objects in the first quarter of the 21st century. A good concept of the existence of an object postulated by a successful scientific theory should at least take into account two contexts of proper philosophical reasoning – reasoning «from science», grasping the questions of the philosophical and meth­odological justification of knowledge at the level of certain «standards of rationality» that correspond to the chosen theory, and reasoning «from metaphysics», which, in the appropriate context, interpret «elec­tron» as an element of objective reality, as if the electron of scientists «actually» existed. Our thesis is that by choosing as the main elements of the concept the Dennettian ontology of patterns project and the E.J. Lowe’s neo-Aristotelian categorical ontology project, we will be able to block the problem of pessimis­tic meta-induction (H. Putnam, L. Laudan, etc.). The electron exists as a pattern that we extract from the whole set of empirical data associated with the theoretical entity «electron», whose «real definition» right now is given by the Standard Model and the accompanying concepts from quantum mechanics. In the course of the scientific revolution, the electron, as a pattern, does not disappear anywhere, since parts of the «real definitions» of the patterns of the old «paradigm», those that can be retrospectively interpreted and functionally meaningfully coupled with the new one, will be asserted within the «real definitions» of the new patterns, which indicates on the existence of a relationship of «essential dependence» between the «old» and the «new» patterns.

1. Chakravartty A. The Structuralist Conception of Objects. Philosophy of Science, 2003, vol. 70. Р. 867–878.

2. Dennett D. Real Patterns. Journal of Philosophy, 1991, vol. 88. Р. 27–51.

3. Duhem P. Physics and Metaphysics (1893). In: R. Ariew. Р. Barker (eds.) Pierre Duhem. Essays in the History and Philosophy of Science. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1996. Р. 29–49.

4. French S. Models and Mathematics in Physics: The Role of Group Theory // J. Butterfield, C. Pagonis (eds.) From Philosophy to Physics. Cambridge University Press, 1999. Р. 187–207.

5. Golovko N.V. Naturalization of epistemology and reintroducing of psychology: the motivation problem [Naturalizatsiya epistemologii i «vozvrashchenie psihologii»: problema motivatsii]. Tomsk State University Journal, 2007, no. 294. Р. 120–124. (In Russ.)

6. Golovko N.V. Naturalization of Metaphysics: Scientific Realism and Dialectical Materialism [Naturalizatsiya metafiziki: nauchnyi realism i dialekticheskii materialism]. Voprosy filosofii, 2013, no. 8. Р. 24–33. (In Russ.)

7. Golovko N.V. J. Ladyman and E. J. Lowe: Patterns, Essence, and Truthmaking [J. Ladyman i E. J. Lowe: patterns, sushchnost i ustanovleniie istiny]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2019, no. 4. Р. 63–77. (In Russ.)

8. Golovko N.V. D. Dennett’s Real Patterns as a Modal Ontology: Essentialist Interpretation of Truth-Making [Realnie patterny D. Denneta kak modalnaya ontologiya: essentsialistskaya traktovka ystanovleniya istiny]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2020, no. 2. Р. 59–74. (In Russ.)

9. Golovko N.V. General Relativity and Causality, Reasoning from Metaphysics, and E. J. Lowe’s Ontology [Obshchaya teoriya otnositelnosti i prichinnost, rassuzhdeniya ot metafiziki i ontologiya J. Lowe]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2021, no. 3. Р. 5–32. (In Russ.)

10. Golovko N.V., Ertel I.I. Ontic Structural Realism: Pattern Ontologyand the Modal Nature of Structures [Onticheskii strukturnyi realism: ontologiya patternov i modalnaya priroda struktur]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2020, no. 4. Р. 5–29. (In Russ.)

11. Golovko N.V., Ertel I.I. J. Ladyman, D. Dennett and E. J. Lowe: Scientific Realism and Metaphysics of Possibilities [J. Ladyman, D. Dennett i E.J. Lowe: Nauchnyi realism i metafizika vozmozhnostei]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2021, no. 4. Р. 5–33. (In Russ.)

12. Goran V.P. Philosophy. What is It? [Filosofiya. Chto eto takoe?]. Philosophy of Science, 1997, no. 1. Р. 3–15. (In Russ.)

13. Haugeland J. Pattern and Being. In: B. Dahlbom (ed.) Dennett and his Critics. Oxford: Blackwell, 1993. Р. 53–69.

14. Katz J. Realistic Rationalism. MIT Press, 2000.

15. Ladyman J. What is Structural Realism? Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 1998, vol. 29. Р. 409–424.

16. Ladyman J., Ross D., Spurrett D., Collier J. Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford University Press, 2007.

17. Lenin V.I. Materialism and Empirio-criticism [Materializm i empiriokriticism] (1909). In: Complete Set of Works [Polnoe sobranie sochinenii] [in 55 vols]: Vol. 18. Moscow: Izdatelstvo politicheskoi litaratury, 1968. Р. 7–384. (In Russ.)

18. Lowe E.J. The Possibility of Metaphysics. Oxford University Press, 1998.

19. Lowe E.J. A Survey of Metaphysics. Oxford University Press, 2002.

20. Lowe E.J. The Four-Category Ontology. Oxford University Press, 2006a.

21. Lowe E.J. How Real is Substantial Change? The Monist, 2006b, vol. 89, no. 3. Р. 275–293.

22. Lowe E.J. Two Notions of Being: Entity and Essence. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 2008, vol. 62. Р. 23–48.

23. Lowe E.J. What is the Source of Our Knowledge of Modal Truths? Mind, 2012, vol. 121. Р. 919–950.

24. Lowe E.J. Some Varieties of Metaphysical Dependence. In: M. Hoeltje, B. Schnieder, A. Steinberg (eds.). Varieties of Dependence: Ontological Dependence, Grounding, Supervenience, Response-Dependence. Philosophia Verlag, 2013. Р. 193–210.

25. Lowe E.J. There Are (Probably) No Relations. In: A. Marmodoro, D. Yates (eds.). The Metaphysics of Relations. Oxford University Press, 2016. Р. 100–112.

26. Poincaré J.H. On Science [O nauke]. Ed. by L. Pontryagin. Moscow: Nauka, 1990. (In Russ.)

27. Pris F.-I. Knowledge Within Context [Znanie v kontekste]. Sankt-Peterburg: Aletheia, 2022. (In Russ.)

28. Putnam H. Meaning and the Moral Sciences. Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1978.

29. Ross D. Dennett’s Conceptual Reform. Behavior and Philosophy, 1994, vol. 22, no. 1. Р. 41-52.

30. Ross D. Rainforest Realism: A Dennettian Theory of Existence. In: A. Brook, D. Ross, D. Thompson (eds.) Dennett’s Philosophy: A Comprehensive Assessment. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2000. Р. 147–168.

31. Worrall J. Structural Realism: The Best o f Both Worlds? Dialectica, 1989, vol. 43. Р. 99–124.