General Relativity and Causality, Reasoning from Metaphysics, and E. J. Lowe’s Ontology

The paper aims to show the importance of reasoning “from metaphysics” in the course of a consistent interpretation of the “against neoscholasticism” thesis (J. Ladyman). The idea that “the subject of metaphysics is metaphysical possibilities, and science determines which of them are actually achieved” (E. J. Lowe, J. Katz, etc.) reinforces the role of reasoning “from metaphysics” within the field of metaphysics of science. The general theory of relativity violates the common prevailing intuition that “causality is the subject of local physical interaction” (J. Bigelow). Interpretation of causality in terms of “forces” and “coming into” within the framework of E. J. Lowe's ontology makes it possible to talk about causality in terms of “finding” and “going out” of existence of the corresponding modes of objects connected by a formal “causal relationship”. The transition to E. J. Lowe's ontology helps not only to overcome the intuition of the locality of causality, but also reveals in its own way, for example, such seemingly simple common intuitions as the dependence of the truth of propositions on time or the understanding of time as a dimension. All this once again brings us back to the understanding of the importance of the fact that a scientist, constructing or interpreting a scientific theory, as a rule, uses non-trivial philosophical assumptions that should be the subject of its own philosophical analysis.

1. Ambartsumyan V. A., Kazutinskii V. V. Revolution in Contemporary Astronomy [Revolutsiya v sovremennoi astronomii]. Priroda, 1970, no. 8, pp. 16–26. (in Russ.)

2. Batterman R. The Devil in the Details: Asymptotic Reasoning in Explanation, Reduction and Emergence. Oxford Uni. Press, 2002.

3. Berenstain N. What a Structuralist Theory of Properties Could not Be. In: A. Marmodoro, D. Yates (eds.). The Metaphysics of Relations. Oxford Uni. Press, 2016, pp. 157–176.

4. Bigelow J., Pargetter R. Metaphysics of Causation. Erkenntnis, 1990, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 89–119.

5. Chisholm R. Theory of Knowledge. Prentice-Hall, 1989.

6. Colyvan M. Causal Explanation and Ontological Commitment. In: U. Meixner, P. Simons (eds.). Metaphysics in the Post-Metaphysical Age. Austrian Ludwig Wittgenstein Society, 2001, pp. 141–146.

7. Curiel E. The Constraints General Relativity Places on Physicalist Accounts of Causality. Theoria, 2000, vol. 15 (1), pp. 33–58.

8. Devitt M. The Methodology of Naturalistic Semantics. Journal of Philosophy, 1994, vol. 91, pp. 545–572.

9. Dowe Ph. Physical Causation. Cambridge Uni. Press, 2000.

10. French S., Ladyman J. Remodeling structural realism: quantum physics and the metaphysics of structure. Synthese, 2003, vol. 136, pp. 31–56.

11. Golovko N. V. Naturalization of metaphysics: scientific realism and dialectical materialism [Naturalizatsiya metafiziki: nauchnyi realism i dialekticheskii materialism]. Voprosy filosofii, 2013, no. 8, pp. 24–33. (in Russ.)

12. Golovko N. V. Naturalizatsiya epistemologii i osnovnye argumenty v polzu nauchnogo realisma [Naturalization of Epistemology and the Basic Arguments For Scientific Realism]. Vestnik of Novosibirsk State University. Series: Philosophy, 2006b, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 51–57. (in Russ.)

13. Golovko N. V. On Topological Characteristics of Space and Relativity Principle Connection: the Case of Dimensionality [Topologicheskie svoistva prostranstva i printsip otnositelnosti: k postanovke problemy razmernosti v kontekste rasshirennoi spetsialnoi teorii otnositelnosti]. Philosophy of Science, 2006a, no. 2, pp. 93–112. (in Russ.)

14. Golovko N. V. Individuation of Theories and Scientific Realism [Problema individuatsii teorii i nauchnyi realism]. Philosophy of Science, 2005, no. 1, pp. 63–105. (in Russ.)

15. Golovko N. V. Naturalistic Turn: Putting Metaphysics First [Naturalisticheskii povorot: pervichnoct metafiziki]. Vestnik of Novosibirsk State University. Series: Philosophy, 2010, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 33–38. (in Russ.)

16. Golovko N. V. The naturalistic turn: naturalistic metaphysics and the cause [Naturalisticheskii povorot: nauchnaya metafizika i prichinnost]. Siberian Journal of Philosophy, 2015, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 27–35p (in Russ.)

17. Korukhov V. V. Fundamental Constants and the Space-Time Structure [Fundamental’nie postoyannie i struktura prostranstva-vremeni]. Novosibirsk State Uni. Press, 2002. (in Russ.)

18. Ladyman J. What is Structural Realism? Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 1998, vol. 29, pp. 409–424.

19. Ladyman J., Ross D., Spurrett D., Collier J. Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford Uni. Press, 2007.

20. Lam V. Causation and Space-Time. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 2005, vol. 27 (3/4), pp. 465–478.

21. Lowe E. J. A Survey of Metaphysics. Oxford Uni. Press, 2002.

22. Lowe E. J. Endurantism Versus Perdurantism and the Nature of Time. Revista di Filosofia Neo-Scholastica, 2006a, no. 4, pp. 713–727.

23. Lowe E. J. How Are Identity Conditions Grounded? In: C. Kanzian (ed.). Persistence. Ontos Verlag, 2008, pp. 73–89.

24. Lowe E. J. How Real is Substantial Change. The Monist, 2006b, vol. 89, pp. 275–293.

25. Lowe E. J. Some Varieties of Metaphysical Dependence. In: M. Hoeltje, B. Schnieder, A. Steinberg (eds.). Varieties of Dependence: Ontological Dependence, Grounding, Supervenience, Response-Dependence. Philosophia Verlag, 2013, pp. 193– 210.

26. Lowe E. J. The Four-Category Ontology: A Metaphysical Foundation for Natural Science. Clarendon Press, 2006 с.

27. Lowe E. J. There Are (Probably) No Relations. In: A. Marmodoro, D. Yates (eds.). The Metaphysics of Relations. Oxford Uni. Press, 2016, pp. 100–112.

28. Lowe E. J. Primitive Substance. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 1994, vol. 54, no. 3, pp. 531–552.

29. Rorty R. Holism, Intrinsicality and the Ambition of Transcendence. In: B. Dahlbom (ed.). Dennett and his Critics. Oxford, Blackwell, 1993, pp. 184–202.

30. Rozental I. L. Mechanics as Geometry [Mehanika kak geometriya]. Moscow, Nauka, 1990. (in Russ.)

31. Rueger A. Local Theories of Causation and the Posteriori Identification of the Causal Relation. Erkenntnis, 1998, vol. 48, pp. 25–38.

32. Russell B. On the notion of cause. In: B. Russell (ed.). Mysticism and Logic. London, Unwin, 1917, pp. 180–208.

33. Schaffer J. On What Grounds What. In: D. Chalmers, D. Manley, R. Wasserman (eds.). Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology. Oxford Uni. Press, 2009, pp. 347–383.